Building A Strong Retirement

For most of our married life, every Sunday in the autumn we would read through the big Sunday paper & ads while watching the GB Packers or MN Vikings.  It’s been about 10 years since we’ve had a newspaper subscription, but yesterday I accepted a $1 offer for the digital version of our local paper.

One of the articles in the Business section was titled “Ten Smart Moves Before Retirement”. It was well-written – kind of a construction plan for a strong retirement. Today, I thought I’d “grade” our own performance against their planning ideas. Overall, we did pretty well …

1. Clarify your retirement vision and goals

1. Clarify your retirement vision and goals

They encourage people to have a good idea of what they want their retirement so they can tie that to the time & treasure needed to fulfill it.  You can see from articles I wrote before I retired, that I had a lot of plans spelled out in quite a bit of detail – including a “Not Bored List” and “Life Wheel”. They are some of the most popular posts I ever shared.

2. Maximize your retirement savings

We pushed to have about 115% of our target retirement nest egg before we retired.  It probably meant that I worked a year or two longer than I needed to.  After 24 years at MegaCorp, I took a job for 3 more years at another MegaCorp.  I enjoyed those extra few years and some of the money I earned went into our “One More Year” charitable fund.

3. Strengthen your rainy-day fund

We were financially comfortable before we retired, so rainy day needs weren’t much of a concern.  You should have 3-6 months cash to cover rainy day needs, but we have always maintained a 2.5-3 year cash buffer in case the investment markets have a pretty severe “storm”.

4. Get a handle on your spending – today & in the future

I tell everyone who asks for retirement advice to figure out what they spend today and how it would change relative to their retirement goals.  Multiply that by 25x or 30x and you can be reasonably sure you have saved enough.  There are a lot of other ways to “pressure test” your nest egg by employing a number of different lenses. We did them all.

5. Prepare your portfolio for retirement

The advice here is to diversify your assets and shift into less risky ones.  I recall our financial planner saying that at a certain point, protecting what you’ve earned is more important than growing it aggressively.  We’re in that situation and so I when I get interested in some speculative investments (like crypto or angel investing), I remind myself to keep it a small hobby share, not a major portfolio push.

6. Create a tax-efficient withdrawal strategy

There’s only so much you can do to avoid the tax man.  We employ a “three bucket” approach to structure our portfolio, which also recognizes which investments are taxable.  We’re currently keeping our withdrawals low right now to avoid taxes and accommodate a few years of Roth Conversions.  Anything we move now will save us taxes when we hit required minimum distributions in 10 years.

7. Make social security and pension decisions carefully

Social Security is still a few years off for us, but we started taking our MegaCorp pension when I turned 55.  Our pension comes in two pieces: one part had to start at age 55 (I’m not sure why); and the other part that we could defer. In the end, we decided to take both of them at 55. Given the performance of our investments over the past 5 years (S&P 500 up +79.6%), I’m happy that we tapped the pension early.

8. Plan for health care

People worry a lot about the cost of health care / health insurance in early retirement, but it’s just another expense you need to plan for.   Many self-employed Americans do that throughout their careers.  I simply sat down with a local insurance guy about 6 months before I retired and he helped me find a policy almost identical to what I had at MegaCorp.  I recall that MegaCorp told us that the health insurance they provided was worth about $18K a year, but I was able to replace it for much less.

9. Pay off inefficient debt

We paid off all of our debt (including our mortgage) years before we retired.  For us, debt has always been a 4-letter word, although I know people who retire with liabilities.  You’ll notice that the tip here is to pay off “inefficient” debt.  Many would say that a low-interest rate mortgage is efficient in that it allows you to deploy more money to investments.  Paying off our mortgage early certainly cost us money over the years, but we’re not terribly disappointed with what we did.

10. Review your life insurance needs

We gave up our life insurance when I stopped working.  All we really had at that point was insurance through MegaCorp, which was the basic 1x salary for “free”, plus an additional 4x that we paid for.  At that point, we were easily “self-insured” for whatever needs we had if one of us should pass away early or to provide for our son, who was finishing his senior year of college.  Life insurance can also be used for legacy goals, but we haven’t planned for that at this point.

Conclusion

I think overall, we were very well-planned for our early retirement. If anything, we probably planned too conservatively, so maybe we could have just retired earlier. The one financial mistake we made was paying off our mortgage early, so that’s not all bad. We probably should have just refinanced to a lower rate and tucked the money into some investments.

How does / did your planning follow their suggestions? What might you add to the list?

Image: Pixabay

14 thoughts on “Building A Strong Retirement”

  1. My wife and I could have retired a couple of years earlier also. Especially if we had known about consulting opportunities.

    For health insurance we were able to use COBRA and then CAL-COBRA to cover most of the years between retirement and Medicare kicking in. When I switched to my own plan, I had some consulting money coming in, so I got to write off the insurance expense. Allowing everyone this deduction seems like it would be fairer.

    My wife and I have done no Roth conversions because we are already in about the same bracket that we will be in after RMDs kick in.

    Our house still has a mortgage balance at 2.75% interest. We think of a low cost mortgage as an inflation hedge. Besides, you always are going to have housing expenses. You have to pay the feudal landlord (Property Taxes) for the right to continue living on your serf holding for another year. There are always household maintenance items. Nothing magical in our minds about paying off your mortgage.

    We did the same with Life Insurance. Think about what retirement is, if planned right, it is never having to work again for money. There is an exception for life insurance, it can be used as an estate planning tool if you are above the estate tax threshold, to pass inheritance Estate Tax free if the policy is held in a non-revocable trust.

    Otherwise, everything else lines up nicely.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I’m not surprised you were well-planned for retirement, Sir. In fact, I’m guessing most regular readers are also well-planned. Still, I hoped going through the list might help some folks that are still planing their FIRE Escape. I agree with your POV on a 2.75% mortgage, but at the time we paid it off (2010), we had a 5.8% rate – so it seemed to make sense. There was a window in 2020 when it hit 2.7% nationally – that would have been a great time to lock-in – but 9 years after we had paid ours off.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Here’s an article from The Epoch Times on financial planning during the gap years, defined as the time between retirement and when Social Security and RMDs kick in. The article had a point that resonated with me about Roth Conversions. If you are in the 22% bracket (I am), do a Roth Conversion in the 24% bracket to avoid having to pay 32% when RMD’s kick in. I am planning to pencil out the numbers and might do a Roth Conversion before the end of this year and next year, if the numbers make sense.

    https://www.theepochtimes.com/bright/the-retirement-gap-years-a-time-to-make-tax-savvy-moves-6095235?utm_source=ref_share&utm_campaign=copy

    Liked by 1 person

  3. The biggest issue of retirement is failure to plan.

    I didn’t realize the impact of income on Medicare and the added cost for the rich in retirement to subsidize the poor.

    The tax efficient withdrawal coincides with Roth conversions. If one can cash out securities in one year such that income will be low the following year to convert traditional IRA to Roth would be a good strategy.

    My deferred accounts IRA, 401K and 457 were all prefunded, meaning that by age 40 I had in combination of years in a pension along with balances in deferred accounts that I stopped contributions to deferred accounts. I failed to learn how important Roth accounts are and I should have converted funds at that time, especially later in 2008, but oh well.

    I am at the tail end of the baby boom (1962) so I had the advice of everyone that in retirement you will be in a lower tax bracket. That might be for many, but not for me.

    The tax man always cometh.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I checked tax rates before the Reagan Era tax cut of 1981 and the top rate was 70%, which was lowered to 50%. Rates were cut again in 1986 to a top rate of 28%.

      Pensions changed from Defined Benefit to Defined Contribution starting in 1978 when 401-k’s were legislated. I think our 401-k’s payouts will be a lot larger than Defined Benefit Plans. Twice my wife had the option of receiving a Defined Benefit Pension which terminated at death, or receiving a lump sum that could be rolled into her self-directed IRA. I did the math and the IRA beat the payouts of the pension plans, without a 50% cut is she passed, and a potential inheritance to our children. I think the combination of lower tax rates and higher returns destroyed the advice we got about making less and being in a lower tax bracket when we retire.

      I just started mathematically modeling doing a Roth Conversion for the next two years. I am seeing that the Roth conversion would be in the Federal 24% bracket and the 9.3% California bracket. It would totally extinguish the Senior Bonus Deduction. The Net Investment Tax would bump my dividends from 15% to 18.3%. Plus is would trigger a $10,000 IRMAA cost two years in the future. By my calculation a $178,000 would only net $126,116 going into the Roth Account after taxes and before the IRMAA hit. This is a work in process, because I still need to model leaving the funds in an IRA and allow it to compound and come up with a comparison of does a Roth Conversion actually yield more spendable cash. My gut is telling me that a Roth Conversion will not yield very much more spendable cash under the current tax law. However, with the Communists we have running for Congress and the Communists in control of the People’s Republic of California rates could get even higher.

      Politicians on both sides of the aisle buy the votes of 51% by giving them freebies. We are part of the losing 49% that pays the bills. The phaseouts shout that message to me loud and clear. I want to vomit whenever I hear a politick saying the wealthy don’t pay their fair share.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Agree. The USA has one of the most progressive tax structures of OECD countries, but I think it’s only going to get more progressive. Ideas like “Medicare for All” are becoming very mainstream and someone is going to have to pay for that enormous cost.

        Liked by 2 people

    2. Agree with you on the tax exposure in retirement. We’re Gen X-ers (1966), so just a few years behind you. I was always told that our tax rate would be lower in retirement, but like you – we’ve discovered we’re going to stay pretty high. We did our first Roth Conversion last year, but our opportunities are going to be pretty limited over the next 10 years. Nice problem to have, I guess.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Chief, did you perform a financial analysis before deciding to do Roth Conversions? This dialogue really has really made me think. I am working on financial analysis that compares Roth versus not doing a Roth if tax rates stay the same. Bernie Sanders wrote about funding Medicare-For-All by cranking up the top end of the tax brackets. Comrade Sanders is proposing raising the top tax bracket between $250K and $500K to 40%. For a married couple the current rate from $211,400 to $403,550 is 24%. $403,550 to $512,450 is 32%.

        My decision might boil down to; this is how much it will cost if taxes stay the same, but this is how much it will save if the Communists get their Medicare-For-All.

        I have to run and vomit again. I absolutely hate the way the discussion about Medical Care is solely about who we can stick with the bill. Never about what can we do to improve overall health to reduce the need. Let’s stop the fraud. Why are our costs so high compared to other countries?

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Yes… We did an analysis with our accountant in the Fall, prior to making the move. We really didn’t have much income last year, so it was perfect time to do it. Probably will do the same again this year. How much did we save? Probably in the tens of thousands of dollars.

        Regarding why America is so expensive for healthcare… This guy did a great job analyzing it. It all comes down to the fact that since we have more money, we spend more money on healthcare. It’s true for almost every product.

        https://x.com/jeremykauffman/status/1866661752181862666?s=46

        Like

  4. Klaus, your gut is likely correct, and I will give you another reason to vomit. What if the thieves otherwise known as elected officials decide to set a tax albeit a low rate on all retirement distributions including Roths but it won’t be a tax but rather a fee to fund social security or Medicare or Medicare for all!

    I had the opportunity to buy five years of service in PERS, and I had enough money in a 457 account to do so. I did not even though it would have been worth it due to retirement benefit based on final 3 years wages which were much higher than cost at that time. I did not as I knew I would have more than enough in retirement and I could pass on my457 account but not PERS. When I retired, I elected a slightly lower benefit so my wife could have full survivor benefits with no reduction. This was worth it given kidney disease.

    I know some retirement people say to take the cash pay out and roll it over to an IRA but in four years of benefits that exceeded the cash out amount.

    Like most things in life personal finance is just that…..PERSONAL.

    I’m waiting for someone to tell me what a fair share is. Remember Steve Forbes when he ran for President proposed income taxes done on a postcard. No deductions and a flat percentage for all.

    Liked by 3 people

      1. Steve Forbes was only in a few primaries as I recall. A friend from High School was his campaign manager. A few years later this friend was convicted for a robocall scheme in New Hampshire. His conviction was overturned at the appellate level. My friend was and is a good guy despite working on staff of US Senators. I think he was taken advantage of by slick campaign people in Washington

        Liked by 1 person

  5. I ran some numbers for converting $476,000 over the next five years from a Tax Deferred IRA. The total additional Taxes and IRMAA would come to $218,886 over the five years, which equals 45%.

    I benchmarked our after tax income with and without the conversion for both the current tax code and Comrade Sander’s Medicare-for-All for 2031, when my wife and I both start RMD’s. Here are the relative numbers.

    Roth IRA at the Current Tax Code, our after tax monthly income would increase by $1,083.

    Comrade Sander’s proposal would replace the 24% and 32% brackets with a 40% bracket and dividends and capital gains would be taxed as ordinary income. Comrade Sander’s Medicare-for-All tax code would lower our monthly income by $2,826. With the Roth Conversion, Sander’s would only be stealing $1,415 more per month.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s about the magnitude of the Roth Conversion scheme that we started on last year. $120K/yr x 5 years.

      I honestly doubt the new Congress / next President will be able to jack up income tax rates that much, but no sense in not protecting ourselves from it.

      I was talking to a friend about this yesterday and he commented that since the GOP / Trump just made the tax cuts permanent, the best they might be able to do politically, is just roll them back. Raising them to 40% seems a stretch.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply